Hamilton Beach Searing Grill Review (2026)
Quick Verdict: The Hamilton Beach Electric Indoor Searing Grill (25361) is the affordable open-grill answer to the contact-grill crowd. Instead of pressing food between two plates, it sears on a single open 118-square-inch grate (serving up to 6), with an adjustable thermostat to 450°F, a lid with a viewing window so you can watch without lifting it, and — notably for value shoppers — a PFAS-free removable nonstick grate that drops straight into the dishwasher. It will not air fry or run two temperature zones, and 450°F is short of premium searing heat, but for fuss-free open-style indoor grilling at a friendly price with genuinely easy cleanup, it is one of the smartest budget picks in the category. Researched editorial overview; not a hands-on lab test.
| Specification | Hamilton Beach Searing Grill (25361) |
|---|---|
| Type | Open (single-sided) indoor electric grill |
| Cooking surface | 118 square inches |
| Capacity | Serves up to 6 |
| Max temperature | Adjustable to 450°F |
| Lid | Hinged with viewing window |
| Grate | PFAS-free removable nonstick, dishwasher-safe |
| Housing | Stainless steel |
| Price tier | $ – $$ |
How We Researched the Hamilton Beach Searing Grill
This overview combines Hamilton Beach’s published specifications with the consistent themes in independent reviewer commentary and broad owner reception across major retailers. We anchor on confirmed data — surface area, temperature range, grate material, lid design — and on the strengths and limitations reviewers repeatedly raise about open indoor grills in this class. We did not run our own lab tests; this is researched editorial buying advice, honestly framed, rather than invented hands-on benchmarking. No payment was accepted for placement.
Design & Build
The 25361 takes the open-grill approach: a single horizontal grate with a hinged lid above it, rather than the clamshell two-plate design of a George Foreman. Food cooks on one side and you flip it, much as you would on an outdoor grill — which appeals to buyers who want that familiar grilling experience indoors. The lid’s viewing window is a genuinely useful touch, letting you monitor browning and doneness without lifting the lid and dumping heat.
The housing is stainless steel, giving it a more substantial look than budget plastic-bodied grills, and the grate sits over a water-fillable drip channel that catches fat. The footprint is moderate — larger than a flat folded contact grill but smaller than a multi-cooker tower. Build quality is appropriate for the price tier: a dependable everyday appliance rather than a premium statement piece.
Grilling Performance
Open grilling on a single grate produces the look and feel many people associate with “real” grilling — distinct sear lines, the ability to see the food, and easy access to flip, baste or reposition. The adjustable thermostat runs up to 450°F, which is enough to brown and cook burgers, chicken, sausages, fish and vegetables effectively, and the 118-square-inch grate handles enough food for up to six servings in a batch.
The honest limitation is peak heat. At 450°F it sits below the 500°F of a Ninja or Cuisinart SearBlast and well below the 600°F+ of an outdoor Weber Lumin, so the deepest steakhouse crusts are out of reach. For everyday grilling, though, 450°F is perfectly serviceable — and because it is an open grill, you flip food rather than pressing it, which some cooks simply prefer.
Cleanup: The Standout Strength
This is where the 25361 earns its value reputation. The nonstick grate is removable and dishwasher-safe, so cleanup is genuinely effortless — lift it out and put it in the dishwasher rather than scrubbing a fixed cooking surface. The PFAS-free coating is a meaningful point for buyers concerned about nonstick chemistry; PFAS are the “forever chemicals” some shoppers actively avoid, and Hamilton Beach’s PFAS-free grate addresses that directly. The drip channel and removable parts round out an easy maintenance story.
Everyday Cooking & What to Expect
The 25361 is built around a familiar rhythm: lay food on the open grate, watch it through the window, flip when it’s marked, and pull it when it’s done. That open approach appeals to cooks who find contact grills clinical — you get to engage with the food the way outdoor grilling lets you, repositioning a sausage to a hotter spot or basting a chicken thigh mid-cook. The adjustable thermostat means you can run it gently for fish and vegetables or hotter for burgers and chicken, and the 118-square-inch grate holds enough for a family meal in one batch.
Because it cooks one side at a time, it is a little slower than a two-sided contact grill — you flip rather than press — but many cooks consider that a feature, not a drawback, since flipping gives you control over each side’s char. The viewing window is more useful than it sounds: lifting a lid on any grill dumps heat and extends cook time, so being able to judge doneness at a glance keeps results consistent and the process efficient. For a budget grill, the experience feels closer to real grilling than its price suggests.
How It Compares Within the Category
Among affordable indoor grills, the Hamilton Beach’s distinguishing traits are its open format and its cleanup. The George Foreman Smokeless cooks faster (two-sided) and smokes less (sealed), but its plates are fixed and wipe-clean rather than dishwasher-safe. The Cuisinart Griddler Deluxe and Ninja Foodi Smart XL Pro both do far more — griddle, dual-zone or air-fry — but cost considerably more and take more space. The Weber Lumin is an outdoor sear-machine in a different league of heat and price. The Hamilton Beach’s pitch is narrow and honest: open grilling, easy dishwasher cleanup, a PFAS-free surface, and a friendly price. For the buyer who wants exactly that, little else competes on value.
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Open-grill design — familiar flip-and-sear experience, distinct grill marks
- PFAS-free removable nonstick grate, dishwasher-safe — very easy cleanup
- Lid with viewing window to monitor food without losing heat
- Adjustable thermostat to 450°F covers everyday grilling well
- 118 sq in serves up to 6; stainless-steel housing
- Affordable — among the better value picks in the category
Cons:
- 450°F max — below premium searing heat (500°F+)
- Single-purpose: grills only, no griddle, air-fry or dual-zone
- Open design produces more smoke than a sealed smokeless contact grill
- Single-sided cooking is slower than two-sided contact grilling (you flip)
- Moderate footprint — larger than a folded clamshell grill
Smoke, Ventilation & Indoor Use
Because the 25361 is an open grill, it is the most honest of the indoor options about smoke: exposing the full top surface of the food to direct heat inevitably produces more vapor than a sealed clamshell, particularly when fat hits the hot grate. Hamilton Beach mitigates this with a water-fillable drip channel beneath the grate — the water cools rendered fat as it drips, reducing the smoking and spattering that dry drip trays allow. In practice this keeps things reasonable for everyday foods like chicken and vegetables, but searing a fatty steak or burgers will still generate noticeable smoke. Running it under a range hood, near an open window, or with a fan is the sensible approach. If a near-smokeless indoor experience is non-negotiable, a sealed smokeless contact grill such as the George Foreman Smokeless will serve you better; the Hamilton Beach trades some smoke control for the open-grilling experience and the dishwasher-safe grate.
Value: Where Your Money Goes
The 25361 sits in the budget-to-midrange tier, and the value case is straightforward. You are paying for a stainless-steel body, an adjustable thermostat to 450°F, a lid with a viewing window, and — the standout — a removable, dishwasher-safe, PFAS-free nonstick grate. What you are not paying for is the breadth of a multi-cooker, the dual zones of a Griddler, or the 600°F searing of an outdoor Weber. For a buyer whose actual need is “grill burgers, chicken and vegetables indoors a couple of times a week and clean up in two minutes,” that allocation of cost is close to ideal — you get the features that matter for the use case and don’t subsidize ones you won’t touch. It is precisely this focus that earns it a reputation as one of the better value picks in indoor electric grilling.
Who Should Buy the Hamilton Beach Searing Grill
Best for: Value-focused buyers who want the open-grill flip-and-sear experience indoors with the easiest possible cleanup and a PFAS-free surface.
Buy it if you: prefer open grilling to contact pressing; prioritize dishwasher-safe, PFAS-free cleanup; want a viewing window to watch food cook; and are cooking for up to six on a budget.
Skip it if you: want top-tier searing heat (look at SearBlast or outdoor units); need griddle, air-fry or dual-zone functions; or want the lowest possible indoor smoke (a sealed smokeless contact grill is better for that).
Alternatives Worth Considering
George Foreman Smokeless (GRD6090B) — Lower-Smoke Contact Alternative
Best for: Buyers who want two-sided contact speed and the lowest indoor smoke.
The George Foreman Smokeless is a 1,275-watt contact grill with a 90-square-inch sloped plate, digital controls and up to 85% smoke reduction. Its clamshell cooks food from both sides (faster, no flipping) and its sealed design produces less smoke than an open grill. The trade-off is the fixed plates, which wipe clean rather than going in the dishwasher — so the Hamilton Beach wins on cleanup convenience while the Foreman wins on smoke and speed.
Cuisinart Griddler Deluxe (GR-150) — Versatile Step-Up
Best for: Buyers who want grill, griddle and dual-zone control and will pay more for it.
The Griddler Deluxe is an 1,800-watt grill-griddle with reversible removable plates totaling 240 square inches, six configurations, SearBlast to ~500°F, and two independent temperature zones. It does far more than the Hamilton Beach — full griddle, panini, half-and-half — at a higher price and larger size. A natural upgrade for buyers who outgrow simple open grilling.
Longevity & Care
The standout maintenance feature is the removable, dishwasher-safe grate, which makes deep cleaning trivial and removes the single biggest chore that shortens the life of fixed-plate grills — caked-on residue you can never fully reach. To protect the PFAS-free nonstick coating, use non-metal utensils and skip abrasive scouring pads; let the grate cool before washing. Fill the drip channel with a little water before cooking fatty foods so grease cools rather than burns onto the tray. The stainless-steel housing wipes clean with a damp cloth. Because the grate detaches, you keep moisture away from the electrical base, which helps the unit last. Owners who follow these basic habits tend to get years of reliable everyday service from it, and the low price means it remains an easy appliance to live with rather than baby.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does “open grill” mean versus a contact grill?
An open grill has a single horizontal grate; food cooks on one side and you flip it, like an outdoor grill. A contact grill (such as a George Foreman) closes two plates over the food to cook both sides at once. Open grilling gives the familiar flip-and-sear feel and grill marks; contact grilling is faster and tends to produce less smoke.
Is the grate really PFAS-free?
Yes. Hamilton Beach specifies a PFAS-free nonstick grate on this model, addressing the concern some buyers have about “forever chemicals” in nonstick coatings. The grate is also removable and dishwasher-safe, which is its biggest cleanup advantage.
How hot does it get?
The adjustable thermostat reaches 450°F — enough for effective everyday grilling of burgers, chicken, fish and vegetables, but below the 500°F of premium SearBlast contact grills and well below the 600°F+ of an outdoor Weber Lumin. For deep steakhouse searing, those hotter options are better; for normal grilling, 450°F works well.
Does the lid window actually help?
It does. The viewing window lets you watch browning and doneness without lifting the lid, which keeps heat in and reduces guesswork — a small but genuinely practical convenience that many open indoor grills lack.
Is it smokeless?
No, and it is not marketed as such. Open grilling exposes more food surface to heat, so it produces more smoke than a sealed smokeless contact grill. A water-filled drip channel helps manage grease, but you should still use ventilation. If minimal indoor smoke is your priority, a purpose-built smokeless contact grill is a better fit.
How many people can it serve?
Its 118-square-inch grate serves up to 6, making it a practical family-size grill — comfortably enough for a household plus a couple of guests in a single batch.
Final Verdict
The Hamilton Beach Searing Grill (25361) is the value champion for open-style indoor grilling. It delivers the familiar flip-and-sear experience, a useful viewing window, and the easiest cleanup in its class thanks to a dishwasher-safe, PFAS-free removable grate — all at a friendly price. Its 450°F ceiling and single-purpose design mean it won’t match premium searers or do-everything multi-cookers, and an open grill smokes more than a sealed contact unit. But for buyers who want straightforward, affordable open grilling indoors with effortless, chemical-conscious cleanup, it is one of the smartest picks available.
Last updated: June 2026
See our main guide: Best Electric Grills.